הבנת ניסויים קליניים: עיצוב, ניתוח ואתגרי המחקר ב-COVID-19

קפיצה לפרק

• יסודות הניסוי הקליני
• הקצאה אקראית והסתוואה
• חשיבות גודל המדגם
• אתגרי ניסויים ב-COVID-19
• מחקר מקרה: Hydroxychloroquine
• עקרונות בטיחות תרופתית
• תמלול מלא

יסודות הניסוי הקליני

ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, מסביר שמטרת הליבה של ניסויים קליניים היא לבצע השוואות טיפוליות תקפות. התרחיש האידיאלי יכלול טיפול בקבוצת אנשים, לאחר מכן חזרה בזמן כדי לטפל באותה קבוצה עם טיפול חלופי או ללא טיפול. מודל תיאורטי זה מסייע לבודד את ההשפעה האמיתית של תרופה. מכיוון שזה בלתי אפשרי במציאות, חוקרים משתמשים בקבוצות ביקורת להשוואה במקום.

ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, מדגיש שסתם צפייה בתוצאות ללא עיצוב מבוקר מובילה למחקר תצפיתי. מחקרים אלה אינם יכולים להבטיח שהקבוצות המושוות דומות באמת בתחילת הדרך. המטרה הבסיסית היא להבטיח שכל הבדל בתוצאה נובע מהטיפול עצמו ולא מגורמים אחרים.

הקצאה אקראית והסתוואה

הקצאה אקראית היא השיטה המובילה ליצירת קבוצות ניתנות להשוואה בניסוי קליני. ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, מציין שהקצאה אקראית של מטופלים לקבוצת הטיפול או הביקורת מבטיחה שהקבוצות דומות בממוצע. תהליך זה ממזער הטיות ומשתנים מתערבים שעלולים לעוות את התוצאות.

הסתוואה, שבה משתתפים ולעיתים חוקרים אינם מודעים למי מקבל את הטיפול, מפחיתה עוד יותר הטיה. ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, מציין שמדדי תוצאה אובייקטיביים, כמו תמותה, הם קריטיים. תוצאות סובייקטיביות עלולות להיות מושפעות מציפיות אם משימת הטיפול ידועה, דבר שעלול לפגום בתקפות הניסוי.

חשיבות גודל המדגם

גודל מדגם הולם הוא קריטי לאיתור השפעת טיפול אמיתית. ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, מסביר שמחקר של מעט מדי מטופלים עלול להוביל לתוצאות מטעות בשל שונות אקראית בין אנשים. לדוגמה, אם מטופל בקבוצת הטיפול חווה תוצאה גרועה, זה עשוי לנבע ממצבו הבריאותי ההתחלתי ולא מהתרופה.

מספר המשתתפים הנדרש גדל משמעותית כאשר חוקרים תוצאות נדירות. ד"ר אוונס ממחיש ששיעור תמותה של 1% ידרוש ניסוי עם אלפי מטופלים כדי שיהיה כוח סטטיסטי מספיק לראות הבדל משמעותי בין קבוצות, אם קיים כזה.

אתגרי ניסויים ב-COVID-19

מגפת ה-COVID-19 יצרה דחיפות חסרת תקדים לניסויים קליניים. ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, דן באיך המהירות הזו כללה בדיקה של תרופות חדשות ותרופות קיימות שהותאמו מחדש. מהירות המחקר הובילה לעיתים לניסויים שהשתמשו בשיטות שונות או ששינו את מטרותיהם באמצע המחקר על בסיס ניתוח נתונים מתגלגל.

ד"ר אוונס מכיר בעלויות האמיתיות של הקצב המואץ הזה, כולל בלבול פוטנציאלי עבור רופאים בקו הראשון וסיכון לניגודי עניינים. הריאיון עם ד"ר אנטון טיטוב, MD, בוחן כיצד הקהילה המדעית התמודדה עם אתגרים אלה תוך השאיפה לשמור על יושרה מחקרית.

מחקר מקרה: Hydroxychloroquine

ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, משתמש ב-hydroxychloroquine כדוגמה מובהקת לתרופה שהותאמה מחדש ונחקרה במהלך המגפה. לתרופה זו הייתה היסטוריה מבוססת של שימוש למלריה ומחלות אוטואימוניות, מה שאומר שפרופיל הבטיחות ותופעות הלוואי הנפוצות שלה היו כבר מתועדים היטב.

ידע קודם זה היה קריטי להקשר של תוצאות ניסוי חדשות. המקרה של hydroxychloroquine מדגיש את ההבדל בין חקירת חומר חדש לחלוטין לבין אחד עם נתונים אנושיים קיימים נרחבים.

עקרונות בטיחות תרופתית

עיקרון מרכזי בפרמקולוגיה הוא שלכל תרופה יעילה יש תופעות לוואי. ד"ר סטיבן אוונס, MD, מציע אמרה מפתח: "לכל תרופה יעילה יש תופעות בלתי רצויות, בדרך כלל שליליות". עיקרון זה מדגיש שהרעיון של תרופה בטוחה לחלוטין, נטולת תופעות לוואי, הוא לא ריאלי.

הבנת מציאות זו חיונית הן לקלינאים והן למטופלים. דיון של ד"ר אוונס עם ד"ר אנטון טיטוב, MD, מחזק שהתועלת של תרופה חייבת להישקל sempre against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against against